I have listened to everyone’s thoughtful and not so thoughtful comments.
First I have to say that I am obviously going to place more weight on the
thoughtful comments offering solutions, as well as the comments from those
members that actually participate in exchanges and, more so, have
coordinated exchanges or participate in our conversations and, in many other
ways, positively _contribute_ to the happy community that we (usually) are.
That sentence was too long and had too many commas but you get my drift...
Also, I would like to very much reiterate that Barenforum.org was started as
a traditional Japanese woodblock forum but has welcomed with open arms the
wide variety of techniques and materials that increased membership over the
years has brought. I would suggest to our newer membership a gander through
the richness of the website
http://barenforum.org.
Many other groups and private blogs have sprung from Barenforum's membership
and are continually announced in the forum and happily co-exist and are
available for members to explore and discuss the vast richness of many other
forms of printmaking. Accusing the forum of being divisive or exclusive or
discriminating in any way is just pure gar-bah-ge and would be funny if it
wasn't irritating, or maybe the other way around.
History shows that about 35-38 people sign up for any given exchange, four
or more end up dropping out or disappearing altogether. Popular themes
result in double exchanges to accommodate the interest but are rare. Should
participation rates decline suddenly, I will surely take notice. We have
plenty of exchanges for everyone that wants to exchange, it seems, and
certainly as many as this Exchange Manager can handle. Assistants are always
welcomed. Off-shoot, off-list exchanges are always encouraged, as in the
large-format exchange and my own crazy puzzle-cairns, to mention just two
examples.
So, VOTING IS NOW CLOSED, I have a rather large piece of paper danged near
full of little notes, categories, and tally marks and the onset of an
irritating headache.
With the premise that we can't please everyone all of the time...
-----
Future Exchange Schedule:
To continue to grow together as a group, I am introducing a "technique
challenge" and have modified my thoughts and suggestions according to
thoughtful comments from the membership.
This "technique challenge" will take place once a year and the "technique"
will be voted on (aw lordie) just as we do themes. If the technique happens
to be oil or moku-hanga or white-line or potato prints or whatever, the
majority will have their say and their exchange. Hey! Remember Michael
Schneider's rock prints?
Try as I might, I hardly see any negative in this as there are still three
other exchanges per year where everyone can do what they do. Can I emphasize
this enough?: I am not transforming Barenforum.org into a moku-hanga forum,
I am not structuring or dividing anything or anyone, I am simply challenging
the membership to a once a year: "by golly let's try this". If the plan
doesn't work, I will happily eat crow, my cats say it tastes just like
chicken anyway.
A once a year technique challenge will stimulate discussion, introduce new
techniques, maybe make some members come out of the shadows, add
"exhibit-ability" to our archives, make our conversations more complete in
terms of discussion about woodblock printmaking, and perhaps someone (else)
can get motivated to gather up all the comments on a certain technique into
a coherent whole, and make our newsletter alive again and our encyclopedia
even a more complete resource.
Contribution opportunities abound in our community.
I also know that some techniques or the sole concept of "structure" are not
for everyone, but we will still have mostly free exchanges for everyone, 3
of 4 exchanges per year free, 75% free, repeat, a majority free, unchanged,
free, once more free and unchanged. As shown by our neglected Swap Shop and
the slightly limping Chinese Lunar New Year exchanges, less and less
structure tends to yield less desirable results, in terms of successfully
exchanging prints. When a theme, technique, paper size, etc., doesn't suit
most of us simply quietly skip it.
---------
Exchange #39:
http://www.barenforum.org/exchange/exchange_39/exchange_39.html
-Sign up begins October 1st (thank GOD we didn't have to VOTE on that)
-Medium: Moku-hanga (to please the 18 'yipees' which are a voting majority
over the 5 'bummers', 5 'whateverdude' and 3 'double-up'). Previously
defined in Exchange 15 as: Traditional Japanese polychrome wood block print
- hand rubbed with baren, multi-block, water color pigments, Japanese washi
(printmaking paper).
Please see:
http://www.barenforum.org/exchange/exchange_15/exchange_frame.html
-Paper size remains the same but renamed properly: 1/3 O-bosho known as:
O-Tanzaku yoko -- a sheet measuring 6.6 by 15 inches (16.75 x 38 cm).
The traditional size of printmaking paper in old Japan was O-bosho -- the
size of two O-ban sheets... The O-bosho sheet can be cut to make three
O-tanzaku.
(We have done this size before in Exchange 24, for example, and this should
please someone, somewhere, I'm sure).
-Paper orientation NOT restricted (to remove some restrictions and please
the free-willed).
-Theme: Self-portrait as/with/beside/under/on top of/resembling/looking
at/pondering/cutting down/living in/burning/caring for/planting/(or, in my
case) hanging from, a tree or trees or an entire flippin' forest if you
wish.
To rephrase: a melding of 'self-portrait' and 'tree' themes, which could
encompass all of those suggestions and more and make for a mighty
interesting collection of images.
Again, a compromise among the majority: "self-portrait as tree" and "tree"
votes are tied, with "self-portrait" coming in as third choice, so maybe we
can encompass all three to, again, remove some restriction and please the
majority of the majority of most of the voting votes. I would remove the
theme altogether but hate to waste all those neato tally marks.
-----------
K.Solomon, Exchange Manager
O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O
Maria Arango
http://1000woodcuts.com
http://artfestivalguide.info
O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O=O