Jeff from Hamburg, NY wrote:
>Hello, everyone. I know this whole topic will upset some people, and if it
>weren't me, well, I'd be upset, too. I cringe at any artwork that uses
>computers, I hate the idea of electric presses, etc. But, anyway, I saw an
>incredible tool last night on television. It was an electric chisel. It
>was beautiful, like erasing wood in fine lines.
Dear Jeff,
It being early in April, I must say I felt your posting could not have
arrived at a more perfect time. I have held my tongue for many years, but I
must now step forward and let the world know that I, for one, could not
agree with you more! At last the voice of reason is heard here on
Baren! Upset? Far from it, I am dancing for joy! Computers used to make
Art? What an atrocity! Speaking personally, I have (for more than a
decade now) conspicuously avoided the use of ANY tool and will not suffer
myself to handle anything which has been touched by tools. Electronic
tools (including so-called "computers") are right at the top of my
untouchable list!
I will admit right at the outset that I have NEVER in my life touched (nor
been touched by) a computer -- I call this "abstinence." I do know a few
people who seem to think it's OK to use a computer so long as they wear
rubber gloves, but given the well publicized dangers of viruses and worms,
I think that is completely irresponsible behavior!
I don't know WHY some people seem to be drawn to tool use! It is obviously
gross and I find it appalling! Especially in Art! What an affront... I
mean, don't you agree that if someone uses a TOOL to make something, that
one must, to a large degree, share credit for one's invention with that
tool? And if one uses someone else's tool (and I include tools which have
been made by others, who likely used tools made by still others) isn't it
really then the TOOL which does the making? Of course it is! And anyone
with the capacity to deeply contemplate (by deeply I mean for up to several
moments at a sitting) that electricity is fundamentally evil and should be
confined to its natural activities of scorching trees and golfers and
raising one's arm hairs when one walks on a wool carpet in rubber-soled
shoes in dry weather... For tools and people to have enslaved electricity
and forcing it to go running around inside computers creating artistic
things! Well, that's unspeakable isnt' it!?
I realize that there ARE a minority out there who secretly believe that
computers and other tools are time and labor savers, and that a few of
those even use computers and rulers and pencils and other tools to compose
visual art and do not admit to feeling ashamed or apologetic... I think
those people are totally missing it! I mean, maybe it's difficult for THAT
kind of person to understand the obvious truth that computers are
completely inappropriate for making art, but surely EVERYONE can agree
immediately and without a bit of thought required that the use of computers
in language would completely destroy us! I mean... Imagine if one used a
computer to produce... LANGUAGE! People would look at what was written,
even the most beautiful of sonnets, short stories, novels, songs -- and
simply dismiss them out of hand, saying, "oh -- that's nothing -- a
computer did it!" or "yeah, but she did it on a computer"...
What I am trying to communicate here is that because a computer was
involved in the creative process, there is no telling where the human mind
left off and the machine mind began, is there? If you ever read anything
typed into a word processor you know exactly what I mean... Worthless
garbage! It's so easy to see that with language, isn't it? So why, oh
WHY are some people so blind when it comes to the visual arts? BAN
computers! BAN tools all together!
I mean, if you use a gouge manufactured by some stranger to remove printing
surfaces from a block of wood, isn't that just totally cheating? And
wouldn't you be worried immediately that someone would say, "oh,
that? it's nothing -- a gouge did that!" or "she didn't even mine her own
ore!" I would and often do!
And that is why my own work is so highly valued -- treasured,
even! Because it is dead-center middle-of-the-road! People can appreciate
that it takes a long time for fingernails to grow back after surfacing and
tearing out the fibers from wood in order to make a woodblock for one of my
prints -- and those self-same fibers are the ones I laboriously weave to
'create' my printing paper -- and my colors (duh!) are also 'organic' and
self-manufactured...
So, my short answer to your question about electric gouges and chisels is:
Don't get near 'em! They'll take over your life and work and people will
attribute anything you make using such tools to the tools
themselves. Spare yourself this heartache. Having been one of the million
chimpanzees involved in the million year long "Merchant of Venice" project
I can tell you that not a soul will appreciate your efforts and you will
become a total laughing stock.
-- Mike
http://mlyon.com